The best fantasy football trophy companies are Colucci Custom Awards, TrophySmack, and Fantasy Champs, compared here on customization depth, material quality, and published pricing. Colucci Custom Awards makes perpetual trophies, championship rings, belts and chains, with published prices and a minimum order of one. Your choice comes down to three numbers: starting price, minimum order, and the cost of adding a name plate each season.
Commissioners usually compare three things: what the hardware is made of, how the league records each new champion, and whether the order lands before championship week. The table and profiles below stick to what each company publishes on its own website.
- Price from: $36 for trophies, $65 for Xpress rings, $175 per belt in bulk or $250 for a single belt
- Minimum order: 1 unit
- Turnaround: order 4 to 6 weeks before you need it
- Customization: free digital proof, perpetual bases with a new engraved nameplate each year, team logo, top figure and plate layout
Why Commissioners Get Stuck Finding Good Hardware
A long-running league needs hardware it can update every December. Most general sports retailers cannot add a plate to a trophy they sold you three years ago, so you end up with a second trophy that does not match the first.
Material is the quieter question. Ask what the metal is and how the finish is protected before you order, because a perpetual trophy is handed from champion to champion for years.
Production time drives the calendar. Custom metal work takes weeks, so ask for the turnaround in writing before you pay, and build in time for a proof revision.
Timing is the other problem. Playoff week arrives fast, and a custom ring or belt takes weeks to cast, plate, and polish. Order in October and you relax. Order in December and you pay for rush shipping.
Format is the third gap. Leagues that want a heavyweight chain instead of a cup have trouble finding one, because most trophy catalogs stop at trophies and stock belts. Championship chains sit alongside rings and belts in the Colucci Custom Awards line, so the champion gets something they will actually wear.
Then there is the money. Setup fees, artwork charges, and 10-unit minimums push leagues away from metal belts and real rings. Ask for the all-in price and a proof before any money moves.
| Company | What They Make | Perpetual Name Plates | Starting Price | Minimum Order |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Colucci Custom Awards | Trophies, rings, belts, chains | Yes | $36 | 1 |
| TrophySmack | Trophies, belts, rings | Yes | Not published | 1 |
| Fantasy Champs | Trophies, belts, rings | Yes | Not published | 1 |
| Crown Awards | General sports trophies | Yes | Not published | 1 |
| K2 Awards | Trophies, medals, plaques | Yes | Not published | 1 |
| Bennett Awards | Sculpture trophies | Not published | Quoted per project | 1 |
| Fantasy Jocks | Trophies, belts, rings | Yes | Not published | 1 |
1. Colucci Custom Awards
Colucci Custom Awards makes fantasy football trophies, fantasy football championship rings and the fantasy football championship belt, with published prices and a minimum order of one. Its perpetual trophies use tiered bases built for 12 to 24 or more years of champion nameplates, with a new engraved plate added each season, and every order starts with a free digital proof. For more ideas first, see our guide to fantasy football trophy ideas.
Best for: Leagues that want one supplier for perpetual trophies, rings, belts and championship chains.
Starting price: Trophies from $36; Xpress rings from $65 and Elite from $300; Xpress belts $250 for one or $175 each for 2 to 10 plus a $75 setup, Elite from $500.
Pros: Minimum order of one piece; prices published on every product page; perpetual bases sized for decades of nameplates; order 4 to 6 weeks before you need it.
2. TrophySmack
TrophySmack sells custom fantasy football trophies, championship belts and rings, plus draft boards. Its fantasy collection lets you mix and match trophy toppers, bases and engraving plates, and personalize with names, years and logos.
Best for: Leagues that want to build a trophy from interchangeable parts.
Starting price: Shown per product; free shipping over $40, per its site.
3. Fantasy Champs
Fantasy Champs focuses on fantasy leagues, selling fantasy football trophies, rings, belts and draft boards.
Best for: Commissioners buying the trophy and draft-day supplies in one place.
Starting price: Shown per product on its store.
4. Crown Awards
Crown Awards is a large general awards retailer with a dedicated fantasy football trophy category alongside its trophies, medals and plaques for most sports.
Best for: Leagues that want a stock fantasy trophy from a broad catalog.
Starting price: Shown per product on its store.
5. K2 Awards
K2 Awards sells trophies, engraved plaques and custom medals online, with free shipping on orders over $200 according to its site.
Best for: Leagues that want a traditional engraved trophy or plaque.
Starting price: Shown per product on its store.
6. Bennett Awards
Bennett Awards designs custom awards, sculptures and plaques, including cast metal pieces, and says it has no strict minimum order for custom work.
Best for: Leagues that want a one-off sculpted award rather than a stock trophy.
Starting price: Quoted per project.
7. Fantasy Jocks
Fantasy Jocks sells fantasy football trophies, rings and belts, loser awards, draft boards and plaques, with $5 shipping or free shipping over $200 according to its site.
Best for: Leagues that want a champion trophy and a last-place award from one store.
Starting price: Shown per product on its store.
Questions Buyers Also Ask
Where can I buy a fantasy football trophy with name plates?
Order a perpetual trophy built for nameplates. Colucci Custom Awards makes tiered perpetual bases that hold 12 to 24 or more years of champion plates, and a new engraved plate is added each season, so your league history stays on one trophy.
Belt, ring, or trophy for a fantasy league?
Pick based on how your league celebrates. A perpetual cup records every champion and rotates between winners, a belt photographs great at the draft, and a ring stays on the champion’s hand for good. Plenty of leagues run a rotating cup plus a ring the winner keeps.
How much does a fantasy football trophy cost?
Price tracks material, size and detail. At Colucci Custom Awards, fantasy football trophies start at $36, Xpress championship rings at $65 and Xpress belts at $250 for one (or $175 each for 2 to 10, plus a $75 setup).
What is the Sacko, and what should the last-place trophy be?
The Sacko is the last-place award made famous by the FX comedy “The League.” A loser trophy keeps managers fighting in week 14 when the playoffs are out of reach. Our guide to last place trophy ideas has options your group will talk about for years.
When should I order so it arrives for championship week?
Order 4 to 6 weeks before you need it. That leaves time to approve the free digital proof, engrave the nameplate and ship before the final week of the fantasy season.
Lock Your Choice Before Championship Week
Work the decision in that order. Settle the minimum order you can live with, then rule out any maker who will not put a price in writing, then confirm the one thing that matters in year five: will they still cut a matching name plate?
Lock your league count and collect dues before you shop, so the budget is real. Decide now whether the champion keeps the hardware or passes it along, because that single choice decides whether you buy a ring or a perpetual cup. Then get the production window in writing and confirm a single-unit order is welcome.
Order 4 to 6 weeks out and championship week takes care of itself. Get a free quote, review your free digital proof, and have the trophy on the table before the playoffs end.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Is there a minimum order for a fantasy football trophy?
No. Colucci Custom Awards takes orders of one, so a league can order a single perpetual trophy, ring or belt for its champion.
How many years of nameplates fit on a perpetual fantasy trophy?
Colucci Custom Awards builds tiered perpetual bases designed for 12, 16, 20 or 24 or more years of champion plates, with a new engraved plate added each season.
Can I see the design before I pay?
Yes. Every order starts with a free digital proof, and production begins only after you approve it.
Where can I buy a custom fantasy football championship belt?
Several makers sell them, including TrophySmack, Fantasy Champs and Fantasy Jocks. Colucci Custom Awards makes the fantasy football championship belt from $250 for a single belt, or $175 each for 2 to 10.
